Wednesday, December 07, 2016

          UC Hastings Role in EU Procedure Project

          The European drafting process remains far from complete, and actual adoption of the resulting proposals will surely be a gradual thing. Throughout, however, these developments will have a significant UC Hastings component, and UC Hastings students will have the benefit of information about these significant international trends.
          Sample alt tag.
          The European flag features a circle of 12 gold stars on a blue background. They stand for the ideals of unity, solidarity and harmony among the peoples of Europe. Photo taken at Milan's main railway station.

          According to a recent book, "Europe is in a period of increasing Europeanisation of civil procedure." (The European Union and National Civil Procedure (A. Nylund & B. Krans, eds, 2016, p.1). This process is the focus of an ongoing project organized by the European Law Institute (ELI) to develop a model civil procedure code that could serve guide EU member states in adopting parallel procedure provisions.

          UC Hastings is playing a significant role in this effort. The ELI was founded in 2011, and is modeled on the American Law Institute, the creator of the Restatements of Law that UC Hastings students encounter in many of their courses. In addition, from 1999 to 2007, the ALI and UNIDROIT (a European institution seeking harmonization of legal rules) developed "Transnational Principles of Civil Procedure," under the leadership of Prof. Geoffrey Hazard, former Director of the ALI, and with the active participation of former Dean and Chancellor Mary Kay Kane, who was an adviser on that project.

          In 2013, the ELI embarked on its current project with a conference in Vienna in which Prof. Hazard lead a session on the ALI Transnational Principles and Prof. Richard Marcus was an active participant.

          Since that time, drafting groups from Europe have generated draft provisions to address a wide variety of issues, usually starting with the Transnational Rules as a template. These drafts have been reviewed by a international group of advisers. Prof. Marcus, who is one of a few American advisers to the project, participated in a drafting session in Vienna in November, 2016.

          "It's striking to an American lawyer to learn how different the rest of the world's view of procedure is from what we have here in the U.S.," Marcus reported. Among the distinctive or unique features of U.S. procedure are relaxed pleading requirements, broad discovery, jury trial, contingency fees and the American Rule that each party ordinarily bears its own litigation costs even if it wins the case. Many of those features have been anathema to other legal systems, particularly those in Europe. Indeed, some nations in Europe have adopted "blocking statutes" to forbid American discovery on their soil, and some European lawyers have been fined for cooperating in American discovery.

          From this perspective, the draft ELI rules on Evidence and Access to Information -- the main focus of the recent Vienna drafting session -- are striking in adopting an orientation that may bring Europe closer to the U.S. model in some ways. Thus, a central feature of the drafts developed so far is that the court may enter an order for access to evidence, and that parties must disclose in advance the evidence on which they will rely. In addition, there are draft provisions calling for the court to consider a negative inference when a party does not provide evidence it should produce, and calling for the court to consider all relevant evidence. Importantly, the draft also recognizes that electronically stored information is fully subject to orders for production.

          Meanwhile, U.S. procedure is evolving in ways that may move it somewhat closer to the sort of model under discussion in Europe. Controversial reforms to the U.S. discovery rules for federal courts were adopted on Dec. 1, 2015, emphasizing that discovery must be proportional to the case. The ELI draft for European procedure contains a similar proportionality plank. Prof. Marcus, who has served as Associate Reporter of the U.S. Judicial Conference Advisory Committee on Civil Rules (which drafts these rules), was able during the recent Vienna meeting to alert the ELI drafters to ongoing U.S. developments that could bear on their work.

          As befits its location in a leading center of international legal developments, then, UC Hastings continues to play a leading role in this potentially important European project. It also plays a significant role in the larger world of procedure, as Prof. Marcus serves additionally as Vice President - North America of the International Association on Procedural Law, which has collaborated on the European project.

          The European drafting process remains far from complete, and actual adoption of the resulting proposals will surely be a gradual thing. Throughout, however, these developments will have a significant UC Hastings component, and UC Hastings students will have the benefit of information about these significant international trends.

          ###

          Go to News Archive

          Share this Story

          Share via Facebook
          Share via TwitterShare via EmailPrint Friendly Version

          Other Recent Stories/ RSS

          Friday, June 22, 2018

          Professor Chimène Keitner Announced as Inaugural Scholar-In-Residence at Orrick

          The “Orrick scholars program,” believed to be the first of its kind in the United States, is an innovation of collaboration that will support attorneys focusing on numerous areas of practice, including cyberlaw issues.
          Friday, June 15, 2018

          The “Great Facilitator” Sammy Chang Leaves a Lasting Legacy at UC Hastings

          Recent graduate Samuel “Sammy” Chang ’18 identified many problems facing UC Hastings law students and facilitated the change needed to fix them throughout his law school career.
          Thursday, June 07, 2018

          Valerie McGinty '06 Leads a Push to Elect Progressive Women in California

          The UC Hastings alumna founded Fund Her after the 2016 election to achieve gender parity in the California State Legislature.
          Friday, June 01, 2018

          Thinkers & Doers: May 2018

          Professor Karen Musalo & actress Jane Fonda co-author New York Times piece – Can Trump block people on Twitter? – Alum builds 25-foot art installation on the Embarcadero – The health care merger arms race – Highlights from the 137th Commencement – Pride Law Fund honoring Professor Matthew Coles – Orrick Attorneys & UC Hastings Students Step Up to Help Homeless – and much more
          Friday, May 18, 2018

          UC Hastings Students Speak at UN Human Rights Council in Geneva

          Members of the Hastings Human Rights and International Law Organization attended the 37th Session of the United Nations Human Rights Council to meet diplomats, engage in discussions on human rights issues, and deliver advocacy statements during proceedings.
          Go to News Archive